Quality Assurance Policy & Framework

The written operational method by which the Directorate of Quality Assurance makes sure that every process that produces a graduate meets a defined minimum standard.

  • October 2023
  • Directorate of Quality Assurance
  • Ekiadolor, Benin, Edo State
Federal College of Education (Technical) Ekiadolor crest
FCET Ekiadolor crest
Directorate of Quality Assurance

FCETE Quality Assurance Framework

This document sets out the written operational method by which the Directorate will do its work, so that the College can show that national and global standards are met.

  • 14 Sections
  • 12 Tables
  • 4 Appendices
  • Review: Annually

Executive Summary

Purpose. The Quality Assurance Directorate (QAD) of the Federal College of Education (Technical) Ekiadolor has a mandate to make sure that every process that produces a graduate meets a defined minimum standard. This proposal sets out the written operational method by which the Directorate will do that work, so that the College can show national and global standards are met.

What is proposed

The Directorate will run every activity through a four-stage cycle of planning, implementation, evaluation and improvement.

How it works

It will be led by the Director, with Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation sections and desk officers in every School, department and unit and in the Provost's office.

Evidence and reporting

Seven standard instruments will collect evidence, desk officers will upload it daily to one data and information bank, and reports will reach the Provost weekly, each semester and each year. Performance will be judged against the indicators in Section 12.

Decision requested

The Provost and Management are asked to approve this operational method and the structure in Section 5, appoint the Director, section heads and desk officers, release the funds in Section 13 on schedule, give the Director a say in admission, recruitment and promotion exercises, and receive and act on the Directorate's reports.

1

Introduction and Background

This policy sets out how the Quality Assurance Directorate (QAD) of the Federal College of Education (Technical) Ekiadolor, Benin, Edo State, will run from day to day, so that every process that produces a graduate meets a defined minimum standard.

The College is a government-owned institution that trains teachers and awards the National Certificate in Education (NCE), the mandatory qualification for teaching in Nigerian schools. Concern over the quality of graduates leaving higher institutions has pushed quality assurance to the centre of institutional management. A Directorate that works to a written method, rather than ad hoc, is the most dependable answer to that concern.

The policy builds on two existing College documents: the Quality Assurance Policy, which states what the College commits to, and the paper on the establishment, funding and effective running of the Directorate, which sets out its structure and budget. This document turns both into working procedures: who does what, when, using which instruments, and how results reach decision-makers.

2

Concept of Quality Assurance and Purpose of the Policy

In this policy, quality is the state in which a product and its processes meet or exceed the attributes, characteristics and standards expected by stakeholders. Quality assurance is a defined and systematic way, put in place by stakeholders, of making sure that both the process of production and the product itself meet the expected minimum standard.

Two consequences follow. First, there must be set standards against which the College measures itself. Second, quality assurance must be planned and systematic, never haphazard, so that the final product can meet national and global requirements.

The College Quality Assurance Policy exists to ensure that:

  • admission of students into the College meets national and international best practice;
  • employment of staff follows merit and agreed standards;
  • teaching, learning and the curriculum meet the same standards; and
  • graduates are not only employable but also self-reliant.

The Directorate is the body that turns these four commitments into routine practice.

3

Alignment with the College Vision, Mission and Values

Every activity of the Directorate is anchored in the College's own statements, so that quality is measured against what the College says it is for.

Table 1: College vision, mission and values and their meaning for the Directorate
College statement What it means for the Directorate
Vision: a leading technical college of education, known for excellence and industrialisation through continuous learning and self-reliant citizens Track graduate employability and self-reliance, including through tracer studies
Mission: produce high-quality graduates who are potential entrepreneurs, through integrated scientific, technical and vocational studies Monitor the practical and vocational content of teaching, workshops and facilities
Strategic goals: a citadel of learning for Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET); disciplined, qualified TVET teachers; professionalism; research in TVET Quality-assure curricula, staff recruitment and training, and research output in TVET
Core values: academic excellence, integrity, respect, diversity, innovation, social responsibility Build these into evaluation instruments, staff appraisal and the conduct of examinations
4

Mandate, Objectives and Scope

The Directorate's mandate is to ensure that all elements of the input-process-output framework of the College are quality-assured, so that graduates are employable and meet global standards.

Objectives

  • Standardise and monitor admission of students, from entrance examination to interview.
  • Ensure that staff are recruited, trained and promoted on merit.
  • Verify that facilities, offices, classrooms, workshops and ICT resources meet the required specifications.
  • Confirm that the timetable and curriculum are followed in every School, department and unit.
  • Prepare the College for internal and external accreditation of its programmes.
  • Track graduate performance and feed findings back into planning.
  • Quality-assure governance and management of the institution.
  • Maintain a central data and information bank that supports evidence-based decisions.

Scope

The Directorate covers all Schools, departments and units, the Provost's office, and the following areas of internal quality assurance:

  • the College image and academic programmes;
  • curriculum development, teaching and practicals;
  • library services and student admissions;
  • technical and vocational teaching, learning and infrastructure;
  • research and innovation, and community service;
  • staff matters, human resource and capacity development;
  • verification of results, certificates and transcripts;
  • punctuality, health services, security and the environment.
5

Structure of the Directorate

The Directorate is headed by a Director, appointed by the Provost and directly responsible to the Provost, with three sections and a network of desk officers.

Reporting structure of the Quality Assurance Directorate
Figure 1: Reporting structure of the Directorate

The Director leads the Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation sections and appoints desk officers in each School, department and unit, and in the Provost's office. Desk officers send their findings to the Director through the data bank.

Table 2: Roles and responsibilities in the Directorate
Role Responsibilities
Director Runs the Directorate day to day; chairs all committees; analyses data weekly; reports to the Provost
Planning Section Plans all Directorate activities; designs staff training programmes; plans internal and external accreditation
Monitoring Section Monitors the input-process-output elements: admission, staff recruitment, facilities and equipment, teaching and learning, and follow-up of graduates
Evaluation Section Evaluates how well the Directorate's mandate has been met for each element of the framework
Desk officers
(Schools, departments, units)
Carry out QA from admission through teaching and learning to graduation; send findings to the data bank
Desk officer
(Provost's office)
Quality-assures governance and management
Committees Cover admissions, staff matters, facilities and classroom matters; all headed by the Director
6

Operational Method: the Quality Assurance Cycle

The Directorate runs every activity through a four-stage cycle of planning, implementation, evaluation and improvement, and each stage's findings feed the next round of planning.

Stage 1 Planning Set goals from evidence and feedback; fix timelines, milestones and responsibilities
Stage 2 Implementation Carry out the plan and communicate it regularly to stakeholders
Stage 3 Evaluation Collect data on outcomes, analyse trends and identify gaps
Stage 4 Improvement Revise goals and resources; implement change and keep monitoring
Table 3: The quality assurance cycle
Stage What happens Lead Output
Planning Set goals from evidence and stakeholder feedback; align them with the College vision and mission; fix timelines, milestones, resources and responsibilities Planning Section Annual QA work plan and budget
Implementation Carry out the plan through programmes, services and initiatives; communicate plans to stakeholders regularly for transparency and feedback Desk officers and committees Activity records filed in the data bank
Evaluation Collect data on student learning outcomes, School and departmental performance, staff and institutional effectiveness; analyse trends and gaps Evaluation Section Evaluation reports with findings
Improvement Revise goals, strategies and resources in light of findings; implement the changes and keep monitoring progress Director and Provost Corrective action plans and revised work plan

Day-to-day running of the Directorate

  • On assumption of office, the Director meets all Directorate staff to explain its focus and mandate and to set a clear direction.
  • The Director then sets up committees for each area to be quality-assured, covering every element of the input-process-output framework. The Director chairs all committees so that monitoring stays effective.
  • Desk officers are appointed in each School, department and unit, plus one in the Provost's office for governance.
  • Desk officers report daily into the data bank. Each week the Director analyses the data to decide whether the Directorate is meeting its mandate and where it must improve.
  • The Director asks College Management to release funds for planned activities, using the approved budget in Section 13.
7

Quality Assurance Procedures: Input, Process and Output

The Directorate quality-assures each element of the input-process-output framework with its own procedure, so that no stage of producing a graduate escapes review.

Table 4: Quality assurance procedures for input, process and output
Element Procedure Responsible
Input: students Monitor admission from entrance examination to interview; standardise the content of the written test and the interview; liaise with the admission officer on what to look for Monitoring Section, Admissions desk officer
Input: staff Take part in the employment process; apply meritocracy in appointment and promotion Director, Provost's office desk
Input: facilities Inspect buildings under construction against specification; check offices, classrooms, workshops, equipment and ICT; follow up on repairs Facilities committee
Process: timetable and curriculum Keep one consolidated timetable for all Schools and departments; check delivery against the curriculum and course contents given to heads of department at semester start Classroom matters committee
Process: teaching and learning Make unscheduled visits to teaching halls; keep a teaching register for each course, signed by the lecturer at every class and held by the class representative Classroom matters committee, class representatives
Process: examinations and records Monitor setting, conduct and marking of examinations; verify results, certificates and transcripts Evaluation Section
Output: graduates Run periodic graduate tracer studies by questionnaire; collect employer and end-user feedback; analyse retention, attrition and completion data Evaluation Section, alumni desk

Findings from every procedure go into the data bank described in Section 8. A finding that breaches a standard is escalated as set out in Section 10.

8

Evaluation Instruments and the Data and Information Bank

The Directorate will develop, and keep updating, a standard set of instruments so that evidence is collected the same way in every School and unit.

Table 5: Evaluation instruments
Instrument Purpose Source of data When
Course content and didactic methods form Lecturers give course contents and teaching methods to heads of department Academic staff Start of each semester
Student experience feedback form Capture students' views of teaching and learning Students Each semester
Retention, attrition and completion form Track student flow through programmes Registry, departments Each session
Staff performance and appraisal form Periodic evaluation of staff Heads of department, peers, students Each session
External feedback form Record views of external examiners, NCCE, professional and regulatory bodies and external assessors External reviewers After each review or visit
End-user and employer feedback form Capture how well products and services meet end-user needs Employers, end users Annually
Alumni feedback and tracer form Find out how graduates are faring at work Alumni Annually

Data and information bank

A technology-supported data bank will hold all monitoring and evaluation information for the input-process-output framework. Desk officers upload their records daily, which keeps bureaucracy small and gives the Director one place to analyze evidence. Access is controlled: desk officers upload, the Director and section heads analyze, and the Provost receives summary reports. If the College lacks a system, the ICT line in the budget funds one.

9

Internal and External Quality Assurance, Including Governance

The Directorate runs internal quality assurance continuously and prepares the College for external review, and it applies both to governance and management as well as to academic work.

Internal quality assurance (IQA)

IQA is proactive and preventive. Its main activities are curriculum reviews, School reviews of teaching effectiveness, student surveys and alumni surveys. Their findings go straight into planning and decision-making.

External quality assurance (EQA)

EQA is an independent review of the College's programmes, services and operations by a body such as an accreditation agency. The reviewers hold a site visit, meet Schools, staff, students and other stakeholders, and examine documents and data. The Planning Section prepares for each visit and the Director coordinates the College's response.

Quality assurance of governance and management

The Directorate assesses governance at two levels.

Table 6: Governance and management assurance, by level
Level Methods
External
  • Self-evaluation to identify strengths and gaps;
  • Peer review of the self-evaluation report by experts from similar institutions or professional bodies;
  • Site visit with senior management, staff and students;
  • A report with recommendations and best practice;
  • Follow-up reports showing that recommendations were implemented.
Internal
  • Regular review of governance and management policies and processes against strategic objectives and regulation;
  • Periodic risk assessment with mitigation plans;
  • Monitoring of governance key performance indicators;
  • Regular feedback from management, staff and students;
  • Open communication, sharing of best practice and evidence-based decisions.

The desk officer in the Provost's office carries out the day-to-day governance checks and reports to the Director.

10

Reporting, Feedback, Recognition and Corrective Action

Evidence only improves quality when it reaches decision-makers and triggers action, so the Directorate reports on a fixed rhythm and follows every finding to closure.

Table 7: Reporting schedule
Report Prepared by Sent to Frequency
Daily activity upload Desk officers Data bank Daily
Weekly analysis note Director Provost Weekly
Section reports (planning, monitoring, evaluation) Section heads Director Monthly
Semester QA report Director Provost, College Management Each semester
Annual QA report and work plan Director Provost, Governing Council Annually

Recognition and corrective action

  • Staff who consistently meet or exceed standards are recommended for awards and for merit-based promotion.
  • Where findings show non-compliance, the Directorate issues a corrective action plan with an owner and a deadline, and checks that it is done.
  • Persistent poor performance is referred to the Provost for action under the College's staff regulations.
  • Results are shared with Schools and units so they can respond, in keeping with transparency and accountability.
  • A QA newsletter reports progress and best practice to staff and students.
11

Operational Calendar and Work Plan

The Directorate follows a fixed calendar so that routine checks happen on time and one-off exercises are planned around the academic year.

Table 8: Operational calendar and work plan
Period Activities Lead
Start-up
(first 90 days)
Staff meeting on mandate; set up committees; appoint desk officers; equip offices; set up the data bank; adopt the instruments in Section 8 Director
Daily Desk officers upload monitoring records; spot checks on classes and facilities Desk officers
Weekly Director analyses data; review of attendance on teaching registers; weekly note to Provost Director
Monthly Section reports; committee meetings; follow-up on corrective actions Section heads
Start of semester Collect course contents and teaching methods; check consolidated timetable; monitor admission and registration Planning and Monitoring Sections
Mid-semester Student feedback survey; teaching-hall visits; facilities inspection Monitoring Section
End of semester Monitor examinations; verify results; semester QA report Evaluation Section
End of session Staff appraisal; retention and completion analysis; curriculum and School reviews; annual QA report Evaluation and Planning Sections
Annually Graduate tracer study; employer and alumni surveys; policy review; budget for next session Director
As scheduled by regulators Internal and external programme accreditation; Needs Assessment Committee visit Planning Section
12

Key Performance Indicators

The Directorate judges its own success against measurable indicators, and the targets below are proposed for the Provost and Management to confirm or adjust once baseline data exist.

Table 9: Key performance indicators
Area Indicator Proposed measure Data source
Admission Admissions made through the standardised test and interview 100% of admitted students Admissions records
Teaching delivery Scheduled classes held, as shown on teaching registers Rate per School each month Teaching registers
Curriculum Courses with contents and methods filed at start of semester 100% of courses Course content forms
Student experience Students rating teaching satisfactory or better Share of respondents each semester Feedback forms
Staff Staff appraised in each session 100% of academic staff Appraisal forms
Facilities Inspected facilities meeting specification Share passing, with open repairs listed Inspection reports
Accreditation Programmes with current accreditation All programmes Accreditation records
Graduates Graduates and employers responding to tracer studies Response rate each year Tracer forms
Corrective action Action plans closed by deadline Share closed on time Data bank
Reporting Reports submitted on schedule 100% of scheduled reports Data bank
13

Sources of Funds

Funds shall come from the eight sources in Table 10.

Table 10: Sources of income
S/N Source of funds
1TETFund intervention
2Professional bodies
3Government grants
4Needs Assessment funds
5Endowment funds
6Other income (conferences, workshops, etc.)
7Alumni donations
8Student tuition fees
Total income

Expenditure Lines

Table 11 lists the twenty expenditure lines. The Director reports spending against these lines in each semester report.

Table 11: Expenditure lines
S/N Item
1Operational vehicle
2External accreditation of new programmes
3Equipping and furnishing the Directorate
4Equipping offices of desk officers
5Plagiarism checkers
6Visit of Needs Assessment Committee
7ICT infrastructure and maintenance
8Vehicle maintenance
9Computers for the Directorate and desk officers
10Semester examinations
11ICT subscription
12Internal accreditation of programmes
13Admission examination for new students
14Stationery
15Staff capacity building
16Staff orientation
17Meetings on QA activities
18Monitoring of teaching and learning
19Follow-up of graduates
20QA newsletters
14

Risks, Policy Review, Conclusion and Sources

Risks and mitigation

Table 12: Risks and mitigation
Risk Mitigation
Staff resist monitoring Brief all staff at the start; stress support and recognition as well as sanctions
Funds released late or in part Prioritise accreditation and monitoring lines; seek TETFund and professional-body support early
Desk officers overloaded Keep instruments short; train desk officers; use the data bank to reduce paperwork
Weak or incomplete data Standard forms; weekly checks by section heads; spot audits
Findings not acted upon Provost receives each report; corrective actions tracked to closure

Review of this method and the policy

The Directorate reviews the Quality Assurance Policy and this operational method at least once a year. The review covers the documents and the way QA is practised, and its findings are used to update both.

Conclusion and recommendations

A Directorate that plans, monitors, evaluates and improves on a fixed calendar, with trained desk officers and one data bank, which can show that the College meets national and global standards.

Sources

  • Federal College of Education (Technical) Ekiadolor, Quality Assurance Policy (College practical work document).
  • Omonuwa, F. E., Establishment, Funding and Effective Running of Quality Assurance Directorate in Federal College of Education Technical Ekiadolor, Benin, Edo State.
  • Omonuwa, F. E., Blueprint for Governance and Management of the Quality Assurance Directorate, and Proposed 2024 Budget.
  • Okebukola, P. (2004). Quality assurance made easy, as cited in the establishment paper.

Approval

Quality Assurance Directorate Committee

Prepared/approved by the Quality Assurance Directorate Committee
Name Office / School Signature Date
Dr Omonuwa F.E Director, Quality Assurance Directorate
Oluwaseyi V. Adaja Ag. Director of Academic Planning
Dr. Uduigwome Comfort School of Vocational Education
Dominic J. Ayuk School of General Education
Zakari O. Sherrif School of Technical Education
Edoghogho Stanley School of Social Science Education
Izevbizua I. Pat School of Science
Okpanefe Ejiro Member

Appendix A: Course Content and Didactic Methods Form

To be completed by each lecturer and submitted to the head of department at the start of each semester (Section 8).

Course content and didactic methods form
Item Entry
School and department
Programme and level
Course title and code
Lecturer
Semester and session
Course contents (by week)
Teaching methods and aids
Practical or workshop component
Methods of assessment
Lecturer's signature and date
Head of department's signature and date

Appendix B: Teaching Register

One register is kept for each course, signed by the lecturer at every class and held by the class representative. The Monitoring Section checks it weekly (Section 7).

Teaching register
Date Time Topic taught Lecturer's signature Students present Class rep. signature

Appendix C: Student Experience Feedback Form

Students rate each statement from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree). Responses are anonymous and are collected each semester (Section 8).

Student experience feedback form
Statement 1 2 3 4 5
Classes start and end on time
The lecturer follows the course contents given at the start of the semester
The lecturer explains the course clearly
Practical or workshop sessions are adequate
Classrooms, workshops and equipment are adequate
Assessment is fair and results are released on time
The library and ICT resources meet my needs
Comments and suggestions

Students may add any comments or suggestions on the space provided on the printed form before returning it to the class representative.

Appendix D: Desk Officer Daily Report

Desk officers upload this report to the data bank each day (Section 6).

Desk officer daily report
Item Entry
Desk officer, School, department or unit
Date
Classes scheduled / held
Facilities checked and condition found
Admission, registration or examination activity monitored
Issues found
Action taken or recommended
Signature

Document at a Glance

  • IssuedOctober 2023
  • CustodianDirectorate of Quality Assurance
  • Reports toProvost
  • SectionsPlanning, Monitoring & Evaluation
  • InstrumentsSeven standard instruments
  • ReportingDaily, weekly, semester and annual
  • ReviewAt least once a year

Directorate Contact

Directorate of Quality Assurance,
Federal College of Education (Technical),
Ekiadolor-Olumoye-Uhen Road, 302116,
Ekiadolor-Benin, Edo State.

07031183585

info@fcetekiadolor.edu.ng